Skip to main content

Shang-Chi Might Be Marvel's 'Iron Fist' Diversity Consolation Prize

OPINION

Whether it was always planned or if the backlash against Finn Jones being cast as Danny Rand in the upcoming Netflix Iron Fist series against public cries to diversify the character with an Asian-American actor went ignored, That Hashtag Show/MCU Exchange has heard that Shang-Chi will be joining the series.

They also report that casting will involve auditioning "males of Asian descent" exclusively. It was never certain if Marvel seriously considered casting an Asian-American actor for Danny Rand (in the comics Rand is white) but Shang-Chi has always been portrayed as Chinese and son of the villain Fu Manchu. If the rumor is true it would add some much-needed diversity to the Marvel Cinematic Universe but still fall short of showcasing a person of color as a lead in a series. Shang-Chi is relegated to a supporting role. 

The report states if Shang-Chi is received well it could lead to a solo series. How that's determined or really a possibility is questionable at this point. The Punisher was also rumored to be getting his own series but those reports were squashed by producers. It could still happen but presumably would have to wait until after Daredevil season two (beginning March 18), Luke Cage, Iron Fist, and the Defenders series. A second season of Jessica Jones could still be reality as well.

After a failed attempt to acquire the adaptation rights for the television series characters of Kung-Fu (a show which featured a white actor portraying a Shaolin monk), Marvel acquired the comic book rights to pulp villain Dr. Fu Manchu. Steve Englehart and Jim Starlin built a story around Manchu in 1973 with Shang-Chi as his unknown son who becomes the "master of kung-fu." He became very popular during the kung-fu craze of the 70s.

Since then Shang-Chi has teamed up with many of the Marvel heroes including Iron Fist. He worked with British intelligence, Heroes for Hire, and became an Avenger. Speculation has the 'Shadowland' story arc of the comics to be the basis for the Netflix series. Shadowland saw Daredevil suddenly using extreme measures to fight crime putting him in conflict with the other heroes of Hell's Kitchen. 

The inclusion of Shang-Chi and the casting of an Asian actor is a step in the right direction for Marvel but on its surface looks like a consolation. Marvel refused to reinvent and deconstruct the Asian-as-martial-artist trope by casting an Asian actor for Iron Fist so they instead embraced the "white savior" trope by casting a white actor to be trained by Asians. Now there'll be an actual person of color on screen but only as his support with plenty of villainous (presumably Asian) ninjas of The Hand as well. 

Hopefully, Shang-Chi will get a solo series but I'm not counting on it. Marvel has very little interest in producing projects where people of color are the leads in live-action. After more than a dozen feature films, Marvel Studios will release its first film directed by an African-American director, the talented 'Creed' helmer Ryan Coogler, and starring Chadwick Boseman as the titular hero 'Black Panther' in 2018. This will mark the first person of color to lead a Marvel movie in the modern Marvel Studios era (1998's 'Blade' starred Wesley Snipes but the film was produced by New Line Cinema). 

Luke Cage is the television/streaming exception where Mike Colter portrays the 'street-level' hero. Marvel's small screen offerings are a mixed bag of great gritty adaptations (Netflix), nostalgic spy adventures (Agent Carter), or loosely strung together ties to the MCU in a middling spy series (Agents of SHIELD). People of color are part of ensembles and the MCU's only current heroes of Asian descent are on the same show.

So some people misunderstand the outcry, the desire for change, the need to be included. As a person of color, we're looking for opportunities. Marvel chose to tell the stories of Ant-Man (Michael Pena played perhaps the MCU's only Latino film character) and Doctor Strange (a lead role that could have gone to an Asian actor) before those of Black Panther and Captain Marvel (Marvel's only planned solo female movie). 

Danny Rand could have been Asian-American. Search the internet under #AAIronFist and you'll get not only images of viable Asian actors but pitches as how that could work. Comic book characters are altered, retconned, rebooted, reimagined, even resurrected from the dead. Nothing is ever set in stone. 

Alas, the campaign proved fruitless but if the rumor holds true Marvel gets to have their cake and eat it too.They hold on to the white savior trope who reaps all the benefits from Asian culture and keeps the name on the marquee. The Asian martial-arts stereotype lives on with a possibility for redemption but none of the rewards of leading the narrative. The Asian character once again at the service of the Caucasian star. 

It'll be exciting to see who they cast as Shang-Chi. I wonder if it'll be anyone that was suggested to play Rand. The "master of kung-fu" will be a nice addition to the Marvel live-action universe. Meanwhile, the struggle for equal representation will continue. 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Best Comics of 2017

It's that time of year again. What comics site is complete without an obligatory "Best of 2017" list? No doubt it's been a crazy year in so many ways and the comic book industry is no different. But instead of concentrating on the scandals and controversies all that matters is the fruit of so many talented peoples' labor who've produced some amazing stories. These are just some of the best independent comics of 2017.


DISCLAIMER: [Editor's Note] Spartantown relies on the generosity of independent comic book publishers to provide review copies in order to post reviews. Thanks to companies like Image Comics, Valiant Entertainment, Archie Comics, Dynamite Comics, Black Mask Studios, Action Lab, and occasionally others, I've had access to some wonderful stories that otherwise I would have missed. I don't get review copies from mainstream publishers like DC Comics and Marvel so this "Best of..." list is far from comprehensive but a good sample …

REVIEW: 'Port of Earth' #3 by Zack Kaplan, Andrea Mutti, and Vladimir Popov

The hunt continues for a deadly rogue alien accused of killing a human. ESA agents Rice and McIntyre abide by different rules which make this pursuit a tense, precarious affair. A city on shut-down, a cop with a hair-trigger, and a showdown that could alter intergalactic diplomacy forever.


PORT OF EARTH #3 
Writer: Zack Kaplan Artist: Andrea Mutti Publisher: Image Comics Release Date: January 10, 2018 Cover Price: $3.99
Score: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
'Port of Earth' continues to evolve from a savvy sci-fi premise to a thrilling cop drama to a thought-provoking commentary on American worker displacement and the otherness of aliens as an allegory for immigrants. It's not heavy-handed mind you but there are layers to Zack Kaplan's story. When you consider the seismic change an alien technology that helps turn water into an efficient and powerful energy source would have on the planet it's inevitable that it would set off a societal chain reaction. Especially for those displaced by…

Fred Van Lente & CAFU Decode ARMSTRONG AND THE VAULT OF SPIRITS #1

Valiant announces ARMSTRONG AND THE VAULT OF SPIRITS #1 – a hard-charging, standalone special coming this winter from New York Times best-selling writer Fred Van Lente (ARCHER & ARMSTRONG, Incredible Hercules) and red-hot rising star CAFU (RAPTURE)! On February 7th, join in a riotous celebration for the ages as Armstrong, for the very first time, uncorks the ancient mysteries of his centuries past – and dares his closest comrades into the adventure of several lifetimes!

Deep beneath New York City’s seediest dive bar, Armstrong – the hard-hitting, harder-partying immortal veteran of history’s greatest escapades – is hosting an invitation-only affair for his most beloved friends and allies! Archer… Ivar, Timewalker… Faith… Quantum and Woody… And special guests from across the Valiant Universe… All have been offered a seat at the table for a personally guided tour of Armstrong’s most valuable and tightly guarded treasure… From the Great Flood to ancient Greece to the height of the C…

NYCC: Dynamite's Next 25-Cent Revival is 'Dejah Thoris' with Amy Chu

The Princess of Mars is set to return to her throne this January, as Dynamite Entertainment announces the relaunch of one of their most beloved characters, Dejah Thoris. Writer Amy Chu (Poison Ivy, Red Sonja, KISS) will bring the strong, iconic character back to the comics in the debut issue Dejah Thoris #0, which will retail for 25 cents and allow fans to join the adventure at this introductory price.


This replicates the outstanding debut of Sheena #0, which broke 120,000 sales. Retailers can confidently stock their shelves with extra copies of this red-hot new series.

This exciting prequel to Edgar Rice Burroughs' beloved book, A Princess of Mars, will delve into the untold story of the classic Red Martian princess!  After learning of the legendary Gardens of Mars from her grandfather, Dejah Thoris, Princess of Helium, sets off on a dangerous scientific expedition to save her dying planet. But things don't go the way she planned when she encounters a mysterious Green Martian…

WONDER WOMAN OF THE DAY: Fitness Model Gia Macool Embodies the Amazon Princess

The closest we'll ever get, probably, to superheroes in real life is through the great work of cosplayers. You see them at every pop culture convention from the very basic to extremely elaborate costume design. However, you don't have to be a cosplayer to enjoy dressing up as your favorite superhero from time to time. Take fitness model and entrepreneur Gia Macool for example. An accomplished fitness competitor and model, Macool is also a big fan of DC Comics' Wonder Woman. She shows her love of the iconic Amazon Princess in her fitness wear, meal prep accessories and even a full blown photo shoot in a Wonder Woman costume. 

For decades comics have featured very muscular superheroes, male and female, epitomizing the human form at its strongest. So when bodybuilders and fitness pros decide to suit up as these costumed heroes, they are the embodiment of those fictional characters in the flesh. Macool looks like she stepped out of the pages of a Wonder Woman comic with a suit …