Skip to main content

Marvel Cancels Ill-Advised 'Sexy' Teenager Variant Cover


The controversial Invincible Iron Man variant cover commissioned by Midtown Comics and illustrated by artist J. Scott Campbell with Tony Stark's heir apparent, Riri Williams, on the cover has been canceled.

Considered by many, including me, as neither looking like a 15-year-old girl, either in body type or in fashion, Campbell took a barrage of Twitter criticism for sexualizing the new African-American teen superhero. Not that Campbell took the slights seriously at first.






Later, Campbell seemed to understand that his depiction wasn't being well received for legitimate reasons and admitting he didn't intentionally try to "sex her up."






In his defense, Campbell is a talented artist known for his pin-up style so the onus should be on Marvel for choosing him to do the cover. The lighter skin tone used for the cover also came under fire but the coloring was done by someone else. Again, this falls on Marvel. The portrayal of young women (and all women for that matter) in comics continues to be a sensitive issue because of the industry's history of rampant sexualization designed for the male gaze.   


As anyone knows, Marvel of all people absolutely does, if you hire J. Scott Campbell, you will get a J. Scott Campbell illustration. That means a thin-waisted, doe-eyed, woman with supermodel proportions. Is that who you want drawing one of the few leading teenage African-American superheroes in comics, Marvel? I don't believe Campbell intentionally depicted Riri negatively. He sincerely thought he was "portraying her as a sassy, strong, coming-of-age young woman." The resulting image was not at all surprising considering the artist.

Campbell is certainly capable of learning from this backlash, at least I hope, because how women, young women, young black women are portrayed matter. Overt sexualization of women will no longer be ignored. More importantly, why isn't Marvel aware of this as well? They had the good sense to introduce a character like Riri Williams, a brilliant engineering prodigy about to take over the Iron Man mantle, then turns her over to an artist like Campbell. That's not to say the image was vulgar or gratuitous, it was just a wildly inaccurate portrayal of the teen character. 

Marvel should know better. For all the progress it makes in creating a more diverse universe, it sabotages itself with foolish editorial decisions at times. As quickly as the release of the variant cover stirred controversy, Marvel made sure to show interior art from series artist Stefano Caselli proving Riri will actually look like a teenager. Whether or not the trending hashtag #TeensThatLookLikeTeens helped spur Marvel into releasing the images from the book that contradict the variant cover, it should take a more thoughtful approach when it comes to selecting artists for its characters. 





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

ADVANCE REVIEW: 'Winnebago Graveyard' #1 by Steve Niles, Alison Sampson, and Stéphane Paitreau

Steve Niles and Alison Sampson have arrived to disrupt your bedtime. What happens when an American family traveling on vacation finds themselves stranded in a small town with a sinister secret? The answer is a whole lot of creepy.


WINNEBAGO GRAVEYARD #1 (OF 4) Story: Steve Niles Art / Cover: Aditya Bidikar, Alison Sampson, Jordie Bellaire, Stéphane Paitreau Variant Cover: Mingjue Helen Chen Published: June 14, 2017 Diamond ID: APR170724 Digital : $3.99 Print: $3.99
★★★★1/2 (4.5/5)
Niles wastes no time in setting the tone of  this limited horror series 'Winnebago Graveyard.' A couple is abducted by people in hooded robes and are sacrificed during some kind of satanic ceremony that gives birth to something I can't explain here. You'll have to see it for yourselves. Then we're introduced to our protagonists, the dysfunctional family traveling via the titular Winnebago. They make the same mistake every person in a horror does, they stay at the creepiest locations instead …

REVIEW: 'Samaritan: Veritas' #1 by Matt Hawkins, Atilio Rojo, and Troy Peteri

Born out of The Tithe, 'Samaritan: Veritas,' takes on a whole new target as hacker Samantha Copeland is on the run and looking for revenge. It's a thrilling new chapter from Top Cow's Edenverse written by Matt Hawkins with art from Atilio Rojo.


SAMARITAN #1 Story: Matt Hawkins Art / Lettering / Cover: Atilio Rojo Letterer: Troy Peteri Published: May 24, 2017 Diamond ID: MAR170694 Digital : $3.99 Print: $3.99
★★★★☆ (4/5)
The Tithe found Samaritan taking on nefarious mega-churches and this time the only things more corrupt are the U.S. government and military contractors. The President is in Samantha's crosshairs but she's also a hunted woman using all her hacking skills and the resources of the dark web to counter her pursuers. It's this complex cat-and-mouse game that Hawkins unfolds while also providing Samantha's background for new readers. Hawkins does a delicate balancing act adding exposition with flashbacks while moving the story forward in the prese…

ADVANCE REVIEW: 'Secret Weapons' #1 by Eric Heisserer, Raúl Allén, and Patricia Martin

In comics, the assembling of a team of heroes is not a new concept. But what if those "heroes" had been rejected for having lame powers? Valiant addresses this question in the fantastic new mini, Secret Weapons #1, starring Amanda McKee - the technopath codenamed Livewire.


★★★★1/2 (4.5/5)
Academy Award-nominated screenwriter Eric Heisserer (Arrival) and Harvey Award-nominated artist Raúl Allén (Wrath of the Eternal Warrior) have given this band of misfits a new life under the leadership of Livewire. What could have been treated as a parody is handled with great care and love as these psiots that Toyo Harada had stashed away after drawing out their powers but considered useless have found a new purpose.It's another great entry point for new readers and a rewarding one for longtime fans of Livewire and the Unity series.

Harada stashed Nicole (can speak to birds), Martin (can make inanimate objects glow), Owen (spontaneously summons a random object at any given time) and thr…

REVIEW: 'Magnus' #1 by Kyle Higgins, Jorge Fornes, and Chris O'Halloran

Dynamite keeps reinventing classic Gold Key Comics characters and their latest iteration of Magnus, Robot Fighter, is neither a man nor a robot fighter. What 'Magnus' #1 is, it's a fascinating piece of speculative fiction from Kyle Higgins and Jorge Fornes that is smart, immersive, and thought-provoking.


Magnus #1 writer: Kyle Higgins (main story), Chuck Wendig (Turok bonus story) artist: Jorge Fornés (main story), Chris O'Halloran (main story),  Álvaro Sarraseca (Turok bonus story) letters: Taylor Esposito covers:  Giuseppe Camuncoli (a), Jorge Fornés (b),  Aaron Conley (c), Daniel Warren Johnson(d) incentive covers: Jorge Fornés (B/W art), Aaron Conley (B/W art),  Giuseppe Camuncoli (B/W art), Jorge Fornés (“virgin art”), Aaron Conley (“virgin art”) Order the cover of your choice! FC • 32 pages • $3.99 • Teen+ 
★★★★★ (5/5)
Thanks to shows like Westworld and Black Mirror, science fiction is sexy again and it's not just aliens and space travel either. Instead, the th…

NEW COMIC BOOK DAY: Notable Releases 6/21/17

This week in comics is heavy with the latest issues in on-going stories with only a couple of brand new #1s we've chosen to highlight. Crosswind #1 by Gail Simone and Cat Staggs is the book of the week. (REVIEW) The talented veteran duo delivers a lean mean thriller that is like Freaky Friday meets Goodfellas

NEW COMIC BOOK DAY 6/21/17 by Slidely Slideshow MUSIC BY SZA
The other new title is a mash-up you never imagined happening. DC Comics' Looney Tunes crossovers have been a hoot and 'Lobo/Road Runner' is no different. Wile E. Coyote travels to the far reaches of space to hire Lobo to hunt down and kill his greatest nemesis of all time, the Road Runner. Make sure to check all these other great books out this week. Happy reading!

(W) Gail Simone(A/CA) Cat Staggs Fan-favorite creators GAIL SIMONE and CAT STAGGS make their stunning Image debut with this mind-bending new ongoing series! A slick and ruthless Chicago hitman. A smart but downtrodden Seattle housewife. Wh…